Absolute & Relative Motion (old)

Motion is the appearance and disappearance of something in a continuous manner at consecutive locations. When the very substance is appearing and disappearing then the motion is absolute. But, when only some aspect related to that substance is appearing and disappearing then the motion is relative.

.

Absolute Motion

Nuclear substance or black hole that has infinite duration shall stay at a location forever. By definition it will have no motion in an absolute sense. It will be at absolute rest. But as duration becomes finite, the substance will be disappearing and appearing again; and so, there will be motion. The lesser is the duration, the greater will be the motion.

For example, the sun has been enduring for over 4 billion years and it has not disappeared yet. That means it has not changed its location in an absolute sense. In other words, it has not moved. This pretty much applies to all objects composed of atoms. But substances, such as, light that are not made of atoms have hardly any consistency and duration. That means they appear and disappear very fast. In other words, light moves rapidly in an absolute sense.

So, there is a whole scale of absolute motion—from absolute rest of black holes to absolute rapid motion of light. The reference point for absolute motion is the consistency and the duration of the substance itself.

.

Relative Motion

We are familiar with relative motion only among solid objects, whose consistency and duration is very large. In relative motion, the reference point is always a solid material object whose duration is very large. Thus, light is not used as a reference point.

We measure the motion of an object on earth relative to the earth. But the earth also moves relative to the sun, and the sun itself moves relative to the center of our galaxy. An object, therefore, can have different measures of motion relative to different objects.

The earth’s rotation makes the sun appear to move in the sky. The sun never disappears completely, only its coordinates in earth’s reference system change. Thus, the sun appears to move around the earth. But, if we are on the sun watching earth, then the earth will appear to move in the sky at a rate that earth’s coordinates are changing in the sun’s reference system.

Thus, relative motion has no absolute value, as there is no absolute reference system out there.

.

Relationship

The absolute motion of a substance depends on its duration, which, in turn, depends on its consistency. The motion of light is, therefore, constant if its consistency does not change. The consistency of light may be related to its frequency. Therefore, light of a certain frequency will always travel at the same speed anywhere in the empty space of the universe. This is absolute motion.

In general, matter has such a large duration that its absolute motion is close to zero. Therefore, a solid material body shall have practically no motion anywhere in the universe. The relative motion of a material body could be anything on the relative scale, depending on the reference system chosen, but it would not change its absolute motion, which is practically zero.

Therefore, light will always appear to have the same speed from any solid material body. The coordinate system attached to a solid material body shall have no affect on the speed of light. This was so observed in the historic experiment of Michelson-Morley in 1887.

.

Matter, Space and Time

According to the observations presented in the previous chapter, matter is a continuum in space. Any appearance of matter being discrete comes from its energy interactions with our senses and measuring instruments.

How does matter as a continuum affect the concepts of space and time?

.

Matter and Space

Complete void appears to be an abstraction, but there is reality of “empty space”. The difference between void and empty space is that void is the absence of all substance, whereas, empty space is empty of solid matter only. It is not empty of electronic substance and radiation. Space that is filled with solid matter, defines the extents of that matter. We may extend this definition to all space. We may define space as “the extents of the continuum of substance”. According to this definition space cannot exist without the continuum of substance. It would simply become void, an abstraction.

Current physics treats space as an abstract, mathematical entity. This “space” is fundamental, and it cannot be defined via other quantities. But we shall postulate space as follows.

Space is the extent of the continuum of matter.

Space thus varies in its nature depending on the consistency of substance it contains. We can now visualize Einstein’s space expanding, contracting, curving and twisting.

.

Matter and Time

When we measure time, we measure the duration of something. The duration of the universe is infinite because matter can neither be created nor destroyed. Therefore, matter in itself has infinite duration. However, matter has changing forms, and these forms can have varying durations.

The most fundamental attribute of matter is its consistency, which gives it a form. As covered in the previous chapter, matter thins out continually from solid, impenetrable nucleus to electronic substance to radiation, to void. Matter of highest consistency appears in the nucleus of an atom, or in the black hole at the center of the galaxy. This matter is at the upper end of the spectrum of substance. It has the highest duration. At the lower end of the spectrum is radiation at the edge of the void. This radiation shall have near infinite wavelength and the least duration.

Matter shall appear at the beginning of its duration, stay for its duration, and disappear at the end of that duration. When we see this process occurring in space at consecutive locations, we have motion. This means that the solid, impenetrable form of nuclear matter shall stay at a location in space forever, and the flimsiest form of radiation shall be moving most rapidly from one location to the next in space.

Thus, time as duration is directly related to the consistency of matter and inversely related to the inherent motion of matter. We may sum it up as follows:

(1) Matter has inherent motion.

(2) The inherent motion decreases as the consistency of matter increases, and vice versa.

(3) Absolute rest is associated with the infinite duration of matter of infinite consistency.

(4) Infinite velocity is associated with the infinitesimal duration of radiation of infinitesimal consistency.

Thus, time is directly associated with matter. We may say that

Time is the duration of the continuum of matter.

Time thus varies in its nature depending on the consistency of matter or substance. We can now visualize Einstein’s time dilating and shrinking.

.

Space and Time

As defined above space and time are properties of the continuum of matter. Both space and time acquire their primary characteristic from the consistency of matter. Space and time, therefore, are not independent of each other.

(1) The highest consistency of matter appears in the nucleus of an atom, or in the black hole at the center of the galaxy. At this level of the spectrum, space is completely solid and impenetrable. Time at each location is “forever”. There is no motion.

(2) The lowest consistency of matter appears in the radiation at the edge of the void. At this level of spectrum, space is the flimsiest and completely penetrable. Time at each location is completely “flighty”. There is infinite motion.

This fundamental motion is different in nature than the relative motion we observe in the movement of solid objects in space. The solid objects are near infinite in duration in themselves, but the duration of their positions relative to each other is changing.

The fundamental motion and the relative motion occur at two very different levels.

.

Gravity & Inertia

Reference: Faraday: On the Conservation of Force

.

Innate Impulse and Inertia

It appears that each particle in this universe has an innate impulse that generates natural acceleration. This natural acceleration is resisted by the property of inertia of the particle, and the tendency is towards a balance. When a balance is reached, the particle ends up with a constant velocity, while the acceleration due to innate impulse and inertia are exactly balanced. Therefore, higher is the inertia of the body, the greater is the resistance to acceleration, the more quickly the balance is reached, and the lower is the constant velocity. This is obvious on a cosmic scale when we compare the velocity of light to the velocity of matter.

.

Inertia and Velocity

When earth is revolving around the sun, the innate impulse of earth for linear acceleration is balanced by its inertia, and that keeps the earth in its orbit. If the inertia was any less, then earth will be flying away from the sun. If inertia were greater, then earth will be crashing into the sun. It appears that inertia decreases as earth comes closer to the sun, and earth has a tendency to move away. Similarly, inertia increases as earth moves away from the sun, and earth has a tendency to come closer.

This leads to the interesting conclusion that inertia and velocity have an inverse relationship. It is inertia that converts into the constant velocity and vice versa. This satisfies Faraday’s principle of Conservation of Force.

.

Matter & Void

The first thing we observe about the concepts of matter and void is that there is assumed to be a sharp discontinuity at the interface between them. Since objectivity follows the law of continuity, we expect matter not to stop abruptly, but to thin out gradually, until there is complete absence of matter (void). We, therefore, need to examine the interface between matter and void more closely.

.

Matter

We use a more general term “substance” for matter because, matter is substantial to us to the degree it impacts our senses. Basically, matter is a phenomenon that we sense through our five physical senses. Then we use the mental sense to combine the input from those physical senses to arrive at deeper understanding. This has led us to the discovery of the atomic nature of matter.

From solids to gases, matter has a lessening impact. That means matter thins out as it changes from a solid state to a gaseous state. This has the effect of matter reducing in density. The atomic theory explains it in terms of atoms moving farther apart. Therefore, in order to study the transition from matter to void, we need to take a closer look at atoms.

.

Atoms

In ancient times atoms were visualized to be matter particles that were very small, solid, indivisible and permanent. Newton (1642–1727) theorized that such particles have mass, motion and inertia, and they interact with each other through force. Therefore, a particle, such as, atom could be represented by a mathematical point called center of mass.

The modern atomic theory was born at the beginning of 19th century, and its first application was in the subject of Chemistry. Dalton (1766–1844) theorized that atoms of the same element are alike, but atoms of different elements are different; atoms of different elements combine in certain definite ratios. The idea of atoms being hard, solid and impenetrable particles, continued to be held.

However, some scientists disagreed. Boscovich (1711–1787) theorized that atoms cannot be hard, rigid, massive spheres because they cannot change their velocity instantaneously upon collision, as it violated the law of continuity. He visualized atoms as point particles enveloped by force.

Faraday (1791–1867) found that when he tried to explain electrical conduction using atoms as solid particles separated by space, it led to contradictions. The Boscovich model explained not only electrical conduction, but also “action at a distance” without using the postulate of aether. He saw atoms as “centers of force” from which “tubes of force” extended connecting one atom to another. Force was very concentrated at these centers, but it spread out and filled all space between the atoms. Faraday’s view of nature of matter is expressed in detail in this letter: “A speculation touching Electric Conduction and the Nature of Matter”. We shall further explore this view below.

According to current atomic models, every atom is composed of a hard, point-like nucleus surrounded by clouds of electrons, which are 1800 times lighter. More than 99.94% of an atom’s mass is concentrated in the nucleus that occupies only 0.01% of the atomic volume.

.

Electronic Substance

Physics treats electrons as particles. In truth, electrons do not have centers of mass, so they cannot be differentiated from one another as real particles. No boundary separates one electron from another, or from the void. It is just a particle-less, fluid-like continuum that fills the atom. The consideration of electrons as “particles” comes from a mathematical treatment of discrete sub-atomic reactions.

Even physics considers electrons to have a wave-like nature. It talks about “electron clouds” within the atom that fill over 99% of the atomic volume. This writer finds it more appropriate to consider the electron region to be filled with particle-less, fluid-like continuum made up of layers of different consistencies. To be more real, we shall use the term “electronic substance” in place of electrons.

From Faraday’s point of view, the electronic substance is pure force, and the nucleus of the atom is the “center of force”. The apparent solidity of the nucleus comes from the extreme concentration of the electronic substance at the center of the atom. This makes the nucleus appear 1800 times more dense than the region around it. But there is continuity from the nucleus to the surrounding electronic substance. There is no gap.

The above description does not contradict any experimental data. In this model, the “particles” described by the standard model of particle physics are viewed as “energy particles”. These energy particles are energies of sub-atomic reactions. They are not actual particles in space.

.

Beyond the Atom

Atoms are centers from which matter spreads out into space around them. It loses its consistency very fast and appears as fluid-like electronic substance. This electronic substance, like Faraday’s force, extends out and connects to other atoms. Physics does not define hard boundary for atoms. Mathematically, the electron is a wave function that may extend out to any distance.

So, the space beyond the atom is not empty. Besides electronic substance, it is filled with cosmic microwave background, light and other forms of radiation. This radiation is a fast moving, extremely thin, fluid-like substance that has wave-like properties; and it is not a wave in some postulated substance called aether. Faraday anticipated this way before other scientists in his ideas expressed in this letter: “Thoughts on Ray Vibrations.”

Physics ascribes electromagnetic properties to this radiation and considers it to be made up of discrete particle-like quanta. The idea of quantum is based on the discovery that the energy of radiation is proportional to its frequency, as opposed to the energy of a wave that is proportional to the square of its amplitude. This confirms that radiation is a substance and that it is not a disturbance in an aethereal medium. A quantum is an “energy particle” similar to the electron and other particles, i.e., it is the energy of discrete interactions observed, as of light with metals in photoelectric phenomenon. In reality, radiation is a continuum in space.

According to Faraday’s proposal, radiation is also “force”. It is part of the same line of force that starts at an atom somewhere and spreads out into space to finally terminate at some other atom somewhere. In other words, the electronic substance ends up as radiation as it loses its consistency further by spreading out in space.

.

Conclusion

We arrive at the following conclusions:

  • Matter appears hard, solid and permanent because of the concentration of its substance.
  • Matter thins out at first as electronic substance and then further as radiation.
  • Any discrete appearance of matter as material and energy particles is due to discrete interactions among itself and with our senses.
  • Where this thinning out of matter ends and void begins may only be speculated.

We may, thus, highlight the following:

(1) In reality, matter is a continuum of substance in space.

(2) This substance has variable consistency from matter to void.

.

Tertium Organum

Reference: Tertium Organum (1949)
Reference: Tertium Organum (1920)

The following is a commentary on the chapters of the book Tertium Organum by P D Ouspensky:

Tertium Organum, Introduction
Chapter 1: Knowledge
Chapter 2: Existence
Chapter 3: Space
Chapter 4: Time
Chapter 5: Change
Chapter 6: Reality
Chapter 7: Dimensions
Chapter 8: Consciousness
Chapter 9: Assimilation
Chapter 10: Motion

Chapter 11: Science
Chapter 12: Phenomena
Chapter 13: Life
Chapter 14: Sensation
Chapter 15: Love
Chapter 16: Man
Chapter 17: Oneness
Chapter 18: Intellect and Emotion
Chapter 19: New Knowledge
Chapter 20: Logic of Infinity
Chapter 21: Higher Logic
Chapter 22: Mysticism
Chapter 23: Cosmic Consciousness

.