Author Archives: vinaire

I am originally from India. I am settled in United States since 1969. I love mathematics, philosophy and clarity in thinking.

The Uncertainty Principle

Reference: Essays on Substance

The Uncertainty Principle

The following post, that I read many years ago on Quora, was very inspiring to me. This post was written by Richard Muller, Professor of Physics, U. Calif. Berkeley, co-Founder of Berkeley Earth.

An excellent explanation of uncertainty principle
Local reference (same)

The key point is that the Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle is an attempt to determine a point location in a dimension of space using pure mathematical relationships. Heisenberg starts out with the assumption that an electron is a point particle.

When we look closely at a particle we find that its location in space has an innate dimension equal to the wavelength of its substance. The de Broglie wavelength of matter is very, very small. This justifies assuming a center-of-mass for a material object as a “dimensionless” point. This definitely works at the macro level.

But the wave-length of matter becomes significant as we get down to the atomic and sub-atomic levels. The wave-length of nucleons may still be relatively small enough to treat them as point particles. But the wave-length of electrons is definitely not small. So, the location of an electron cannot assumed to be a dimensionless point within the smallness of the inside of an atom.

The error in Quantum mechanics has been to continue with the point particle assumption at atomic and sub-atomic levels, where it does not apply.

If this is properly understood and we can correct the mathematics being applied at quantum levels; then probably it will lead to much simpler understanding of the quantum phenomenon.

.

Quantum Entanglement

Reference: Essays on Substance

Quantum Entanglement

Quantum entanglement is a strange and fundamental phenomenon in quantum physics where two particles become intrinsically linked, regardless of the distance between them. In this phenomenon, measuring a property of one particle instantly determines the corresponding property of its entangled partner, even if they are separated by vast distances.

But are there really two entangled particles with a vast distance between them? Or, is it the same “particle” stretched over that vast distance? The latter possibility is not surprising looking at how rapidly substance expands as its consistency reduces.

In a hydrogen atom, which contains only one proton and one electron, the electron is the size of the atom; whereas, proton is the size of the extremely small nucleus at the center. The electron has 1/1836 of the mass of the proton, but it is about 10,000 times the size of the proton. The size of a quantum particle appears to have an inverse relationship with its consistency. The photon of light is likely to still be larger by many orders of magnitude.

This above view from The Theory of Substance goes against the “point particle” view of Quantum mechanics. “Point” is a mathematical concept. A dimensionless point does not exist in reality. A “material point” is not dimensionless and it can expand in size.

This matter-centric fixation of Quantum mechanics comes from the Copenhagen interpretation, which is used to interpret all quantum phenomena to this day. Einstein disagreed with this interpretation, and the discontinuity it implied.

Einstein was right! The Theory of Substance agrees with Einstein’s view of continuity. This continuity is an inherent characteristic of The Scientific Method.

.

Concepts in Quantum Mechanics

Reference: Essays on Substance

Concepts in Quantum Mechanics

Any discussion on Quantum Mechanics requires a working knowledge of the following terms. The terms and their definitions are provided in this post for assistance in future discussions on Quantum Mechanics.

Quantum Object
A quantum object is a fundamental unit of matter or energy, such as, atoms, ions, electrons, and photons that is treated as being part of a quantum system.

Quantum System
A quantum system is a system that obeys the laws of quantum mechanics, or the quantum principles.

Quantum Principles
The quantum principles are: (a) Wave-Particle Duality, (b) Quantization, (c) Uncertainty Principle, (d) Superposition, and (e) Quantum Entanglement.

Wave-Particle Duality
Wave-particle duality is a fundamental concept in quantum mechanics that describes the dual nature of quantum objects exhibiting both wave-like and particle-like properties depending on the experimental circumstances.

Quantization
Quantization is a fundamental principle in quantum mechanics that describes how certain physical properties are restricted to discrete values rather than continuous ranges.

Uncertainty Principle
The Uncertainty Principle is a fundamental concept in quantum mechanics that states there is a limit to the precision with which certain pairs of physical properties of a particle can be simultaneously known. This principle applies to complementary variables such as position and momentum, or energy and time.

Superposition
Superposition is a fundamental concept in quantum mechanics that describes the ability of quantum systems to exist in multiple states simultaneously until it is measured. It is mathematically represented as a linear combination of all possible states of a system. This principle is a direct consequence of the linear nature of the Schrödinger equation, which allows for linear combinations of solutions to represent valid quantum states.

Quantum Entanglement
Quantum entanglement is a fundamental principle in quantum mechanics where two or more particles become inextricably linked, sharing a collective quantum state even when separated by vast distances.

Quantum State
A quantum state is a mathematical representation that embodies the complete knowledge of a quantum system. It describes the physical properties and behavior of quantum objects. It is inherently probabilistic in nature.

Quantum Numbers
Quantum numbers are used to describe a quantum state. These are discrete values that describe specific properties of the system. For electrons in atoms, these typically include: (a) Principal quantum number, (b) Angular momentum quantum number, (c) Magnetic quantum number, and (d) Spin quantum number.

Schrödinger Equation
The Schrödinger equation is the fundamental equation that describes the behavior of quantum systems. Just as Newton’s second law governs classical mechanics, the Schrödinger equation governs quantum mechanics. It provides a mathematical framework to determine the wave function of a quantum system.

Wave Function
A wave function is a fundamental concept in quantum mechanics that describes the quantum state of a particle or system. It is a mathematical function that encapsulates all the measurable information about a quantum object. The square of the wave function’s magnitude represents the probability density of finding the particle at a specific position and time.

Wave Function Collapse
Wave function collapse describes the transition of a quantum system from a superposition of multiple states to a single definite state upon measurement or observation. This phenomenon occurs when a wave function, initially representing various possible states of a quantum system, abruptly reduces to one specific eigenstate. The probability of collapsing to a particular state is determined by the wave function before the collapse.

Observable
An observable is a physical property or quantity, such as, position, momentum, angular momentum, spin, etc., that can be measured. Observables play a crucial role in describing and understanding quantum systems.

Eigenstate
An eigenstate is a specific quantum state of a system for which a particular observable has a definite, predictable value. When a quantum system is in an eigenstate of an observable, any measurement of that observable will always yield the same result, known as the eigenvalue. Eigenstates are solutions to the time-independent Schrödinger equation.

Eigenvalue
The eigenvalues of an observable operator correspond to the possible outcomes of a measurement of that observable. When a measurement is performed, the quantum state “collapses” into one of the eigenstates of the observable being measured.

.

Obviously, some aspects of QM do work in spite of its law of wave-particle duality. This doesn’t necessarily mean that, in reality, there is a wave-particle duality. The reality is that there is a wide variability in the rigidity of mass as noted in The Rigidity of Mass.

But if we can only handle the misinterpretations in QM, we can not only simplify its math; but we can also open the door to many more possibilities that we cannot see at the moment.

.

The Spectrum of Substance

Reference: Postulate Mechanics

The Spectrum of Substance

Einstein, in his discovery of quantum, did miss out on the spectrum of substance because he has not fully worked out the philosophic foundation. Please see The Foundation.

This spectrum is pointed out in the Theory of Substance as follows:

Substance of very high consistency in the nucleus of an atom may still be called mass, because it appears as “solid particles.” In contrast, the substance filling the rest of the atom (electrons) is of lower consistency, and it appears as “liquid particles.” The substance beyond the boundary of the atom (electromagnetic radiation) is of very low consistency, and it appears as “gaseous particles.”

For electromagnetic radiation (EMR), the consistency is indicated by the frequency/wavelength. Using de Broglie’s equations, the equivalent frequency/wavelength may be determined for the substance inside an atom that makes up matter; and therefore its consistency. This then provides a spectrum of substance in terms of its consistency.

CONSISTENCY AND SPECTRUM
The consistency may be measured in terms of doubling of frequency. The frequency is usually defined as a power of 10 for EMR. So we may say,

Consistency (C) = log f / log 2

We may calculate the consistency of the substance inside the atom as follows:

De Broglie Equation, λ = h/p,
where h is Planck’s constant, and p is momentum of the “particle” of substance.

Frequency: f = c/λ = (c/h) p = 4.528 x 1041 p

Consistency (C) = (log f) / (log 2) = 138.4 + 3.322 log p

Knowing the mass and velocity, we may calculate the momentum; and then the consistency of a mass particle inside the atom. The spectrum of substance then appears as follows:

This spectrum shows that the the transition from “solid” to “liquid” particles at the boundary of the nucleus must overcome a large difference in consistency from 77.6 to 66.7. But the transition from “liquid” to “gaseous” particles at the boundary of the atom is quite smooth at a consistency around 65-66.

CHARGE IN THE ATOM
The large gap at the boundary of the nucleus is likely to generate much tension. No wonder that the charge in the atom is generated at this boundary.

WAVE-PARTICLE DUALITY
The understanding that electrons are “liquid particles,” and photons are “gaseous particles,” resolves the riddle of wave-particle duality, because such particles can split and combine back in the Double-slit experiment.

.

The Particle-Wave Contradiction (old)

Reference: Essays on Substance

The Particle-Wave Contradiction

Light is neither a wave that requires a medium, nor it is a particle that requires a center of mass. Light is a continuous substance that has consistency. The same goes for an electron.

The electron is like a homogenous drop of substance. By itself, an electron may be represented mathematically as a point particle; but it is indistinguishable from other electrons inside the electronic fluid that swirls around the nucleus of an atom. It is obvious from the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle that electrons are not point particles in a literal sense with exactly defined locations.

The consistency of electrons is very small compared to the nucleus, but their volume is very large. The electronic substance flows homogeneously throughout this volume. Therefore, the electrons have wave properties represented by de Broglie wavelength. Electrons have their own medium, they are not waves in another medium. Electrons are also homogeneous with a volume, and are not point particles, in a literal sense, that cannot be split.

The electrons can easily split as homogenous drops of electronic fluid in the double-slit experiment and splatter on the back screen making “point” impressions. When accumulated in sufficient quantity, such impressions generate the interference pattern typical of wave characteristics.

The discrete energy levels in the electronic region of an atom are resonances similar to the interference patterns. These energy levels decrease in their consistency the farther they get from the nucleus. They, ultimately, reduce to the same consistency as the surrounding electromagnetic fluid and merge into it.

Quantum mechanics confuses the discreteness of these energy levels with the “discreteness” of electrons.

.